NUMBERS 31 — THE WAR AGAINST MIDIAN: JUDGMENT AND ITS AFTERMATH
Why kill the women and boys? This looks like genocide. Study Numbers 31 with context, apologetic analysis, and cross-references.
Numbers 313 questions
Source linked
Commentary provenance
Dr. Lucas D. Shallua Commentary · NUMBERS 31 — THE WAR AGAINST MIDIAN: JUDGMENT AND ITS AFTERMATH
01
The precise difficulties
Why kill the women and boys? This looks like genocide.
Why is Balaam's death recorded so matter-of-factly?
Why the elaborate plunder accounting?
02
Verse and question study
Why kill the women and boys? This looks like genocide.
The chapter must be read strictly within its stated scope: a judicial sentence on the specific Midianite clans that waged spiritual warfare on Israel (25:16–18; 31:16), executed by divine command — the same category as the flood, Sodom, and Jericho. It is not a racial program: Midianites as an ethnic group persist (Judges 6–8; 1 Kings 11:18; Habakkuk 3:7), and Israel's own law later protects Midianite individuals (Deut 10:19 treats the sojourner kindly; Moses' own family was Midianite). God's right over life, exercised in temporal judgment, is the ultimate theological claim (Deut 32:39; 1 Sam 2:6; Job 1:21). The New Covenant community holds no such commission — the Church's weapons are spiritual (2 Cor 10:4), and eschatological judgment belongs to the returning Christ, not to the sword of any nation (Rev 19).
Why is Balaam's death recorded so matter-of-factly?
Because Balaam is the chapter's true target. The kings are named and slain, but Balaam — the spiritual engineer of the whole catastrophe — receives one terse line: "they also killed Balaam the son of Beor with the sword." It is Scripture's verdict on a man who knew God's words and loved the wages of unrighteousness (2 Pet 2:15; Jude 11).
Why the elaborate plunder accounting?
Justice and holiness. Every captive, animal, and shekel is counted before God; the LORD's portion is lifted first; the Levites and priests are provided for from the war's fruit. Israel's wars are not private enterprise.
03
Historical and literary context
Numbers 31 executes the sentence decreed in 25:16–18: "Harass the Midianites and strike them down, for they have harassed you with their wiles." The wiles are specified in 31:16 — the women who seduced Israel acted "on Balaam's advice." This is the last military campaign of Moses' life, commanded and led under his direction (Phinehas carries the holy vessels and trumpets), and it precedes the Transjordan settlement of chapter 32.
04
Apologetic note
The chapter's specific geography — the plains of Moab, the return to the camp opposite Jericho — fits the Transjordan setting. The naming of five Midianite kings matches the clan-based political structure of Transjordanian Midian known from later periods (compare the five Midianite kings of Judges 8). Balaam's presence in the campaign, and his death, coheres with the Deir 'Alla inscription's portrait of a Transjordanian seer — a historical figure anchored in the same region and era.