Does Jesus forbid all divorce? Study Matthew 19 with context, apologetic analysis, and cross-references.
Matthew 196 questions
Source linked
Commentary provenance
Dr. Lucas D. Shallua Commentary · Matthew 19
01
The precise difficulties
Does Jesus forbid all divorce?
Is Jesus commanding all Christians to sell their possessions?
Can a rich person be saved?
What does it mean to be a eunuch for the sake of the kingdom?
What does the promise of a hundredfold mean?
What does "many who are first will be last, and the last first" mean?
02
Verse and question study
Does Jesus forbid all divorce?
Jesus affirms the creation ideal: marriage is a lifelong covenant between one man and one woman. He acknowledges that Moses permitted divorce because of hardness of heart, and He provides an exception for sexual immorality. Paul adds another exception in 1 Corinthians 7:15 for desertion by an unbelieving spouse. The consistent teaching is that divorce is not God's ideal, but in a fallen world, it is sometimes a tragic necessity. The church must hold up the ideal while extending grace to those who have experienced the pain of broken marriages.
Is Jesus commanding all Christians to sell their possessions?
No. Jesus' command to the rich young man was specific to him. The man's wealth was his idol, and Jesus exposed it. For others, the idol may be different. The principle is that whatever we cling to more than Christ must be surrendered. Some are called to give away everything; others are called to steward their resources for the kingdom. The key is that Christ must be first.
Can a rich person be saved?
Yes, but only by a miracle of God. Jesus says it is impossible with man but possible with God. Wealth is a spiritual danger because it creates a false sense of security and self-sufficiency. But God's grace can save anyone, rich or poor. The rich are not excluded from the kingdom; they are simply unable to enter it on their own terms.
What does it mean to be a eunuch for the sake of the kingdom?
It means to embrace celibacy for the sake of the gospel. Some are called to singleness, not because they are unable to marry, but because the kingdom requires it. Paul was such a person. Jesus Himself was single. The saying is a recognition that the kingdom sometimes demands a different path. The one who can receive this should receive it.
What does the promise of a hundredfold mean?
The hundredfold is not a promise of material wealth. It is a promise of spiritual abundance. Those who have left everything for Christ receive a new family in the community of faith, a new purpose in the kingdom, and a new inheritance in heaven. The hundredfold is the joy of knowing Christ and being part of His family. It is far greater than anything we give up.
What does "many who are first will be last, and the last first" mean?
The values of the kingdom invert the values of the world. Those who are first in this world — the rich, the powerful, the respected — may be last in the kingdom. Those who are last in this world — the poor, the humble, the overlooked — may be first. The kingdom is not a meritocracy. It is a kingdom of grace, and its values are not our values.
03
Historical and literary context
Chapter 18 ended with the parable of the unforgiving servant. Now Jesus leaves Galilee for the last time and enters Judea, on the way to Jerusalem and the cross. The setting shifts from the intimacy of the disciples to the scrutiny of the Pharisees. Matthew arranges four encounters: the test about divorce, the blessing of children, the rich young man, and the promise of reward. Each one exposes a different obstacle to the kingdom: hardness of heart, pride, wealth, and self-sufficiency. The chapter is a study in what keeps people out and what brings people in. The King is on the road to Jerusalem, and He is teaching His disciples what it means to follow Him.
04
Apologetic note
Some critics argue that Jesus' teaching on divorce is unrealistic and harmful, especially to women in abusive situations. But Jesus' teaching must be understood in its first-century context. In a culture where men could divorce their wives for almost any reason, Jesus' words were a protective measure, elevating the dignity of women and the sanctity of marriage. The church has always recognized that there are tragic circumstances where divorce is the lesser of two evils. The ideal remains, but grace abounds. The command to the rich young ruler is not a universal law but a specific word. Critics who use it to argue that Jesus was a socialist or an ascetic miss the point entirely. Jesus was not advocating poverty as a virtue; He was exposing the idolatry of wealth. Moreover, the promise of reward in verses 28-29 is not a later invention. It is consistent with the rest of Scripture. The disciples did leave everything, and they did receive a new family in the church. The hundredfold is not material wealth; it is spiritual abundance. The most plausible explanation for these accounts is that they preserve genuine historical memory.